FFXIV vs. FFXI

06.27.2010

Square Enix has claimed over and over that FFXIV would not be a replacement for FFXI. They can put their foot in their mouth. FFXI’s earliest release was in 2002, and it’s about time the game died down. With recent server merges due to low population, including my home server, we are saying goodbye to the FFXI we knew. There was a time, before FFXIV was released, I remember reading on a forum that in one of their fiscal reports, S-E had stated there was something they had planned to be a replacement for FFXI, but back then we didn’t know what it was.  Let’s look at the comparisons;

Environments

Photobucket

Comparison to Kuftal Tunnel.

Photobucket

Comparison to Davoi, includes bridge in both screenshots and similar textures in the rocks.

Photobucket

Comparison to La Theine Plateau, again similar textures, as well as similar trees.

Emblems & City-states

PhotobucketPhotobucketPhotobucket

The 3 city states of FFXIV. FFXI had San d’ Oria, Windurst and Bastok. The emblem of Bastok has a similar boarder as Ul’dah and they are both centered around mineral crafting. San ‘d Oria and Limsa Lominsa both have their own armies (Navy in Limsa’s case) that are referred to as “knights”, as well as similar emblems. Windurst and Gridania are both woodsy nature areas and both are home to Oracles.

You will see many similarities between the two games (races, hairstyles, mobs, bosses), and after watching many game play trailers, seeing screenshots, talking  to alpha testers, it’s apparent it will be a very similar game. If you liked FFXI then you will probably like FFXIV, if you didn’t well… I wouldn’t recommend it. Personally I hope it will be different enough that it won’t be reminiscent of what I already spent 5 years playing.

The video at the top is an exerpt of one of FFXIV’s in-game cutscenes. If you want to see more videos, they are all over youtube. There is also a tester by the name of “Pooky Poo” who leaked 2 full hours of game play (it’s not super exciting), I’ll leave it up to you guys to find that if you’re interested.


Allowei

I live out in Seattle, Washington and work in the gaming industry. Gaming and I have a casual relationship right now, as I was big on MMOs for many years. I won't hesitate to get competitive though! I'm also a fan of anime and most things nerdy. I'd rather watch the History and Discovery channel more than anything else when I'm in front of the TV! Back in the day I jumped from Super Nintendo, to Dreamcast, to the original XBOX. By most gamer's standards I was deprived. High school was the first time I really got serious about games when a friend of mine got me in to Ragnarok Online. From there I jumped to L2 and FFXI. Now I play many genres and styles of games, and am nerdier than ever!



  • http://www.brokeplanet.com James

    Interesting article. Cant wait to play FFXIV.

  • http://blog.princeporter.com Porter

    Definitely looks like they’re trying to migrate players from XI to XIV, at least make it comfortable for those who do. As far as XIV goes, I think it’ll be it’s own unique game; I know I’m looking forward to it.

  • Tom

    Wow! & This just opens up so many more possibility. It could be SE is copying from REAL LIFE AREAS. I mean, did you see the inside of that cave? It looks nearly identical to caves in real life. Bridges!? Fucking, those are man made technology, and here they are using it in a VIDEO GAME!! Let alone, that huge plain with the tree in it. You know what else has trees? Real life.

    & Holy Shit!! They are using the same RGB color differences as we do in design IN REAL LIFE. CONSPIRACY I SAY!

    I’ll just leave this here..

    Also, whoever wrote this article is an idiot.

  • Allowei

    Hey Tom, sorry to hear that. You can make an official complaint to me here:

    http://clgamer.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/butthurt-report-form-internet-version.jpg

  • Quix

    I bought FF14 today to sate my curiousity but certain I won’t leave FF11 nor devote most of my playtime to FF14.

    No matter how good everyone says 14 is, I’m sticking by FF11. Why? Because I’ve been with 11 so long (since 2004), gained so many friends and accomplished so much I can’t bear to start all over again. Most likely I’ll be with FF11 when they shut the servers down which, contrary to what many people think, won’t happen anytime soon.

    To quote John Milton in his book, “Paradise Lost”, “Better to rule in Hell than to serve in Heaven”